The Supreme Court granted leave to appeal to Hubert Deane and John Lohan on 1 June 2016, in a dispute over two houses at Williamstown, County Galway.
Mr Deane trades as Hubert Deane & Associates. He was the supervising consulting engineer on the houses. Mr Lohan trades as John Lohan Groundwork Contractor. His work included the foundations.
Liam Brandley, the developer, and his company WJB Developments Limited sued both men for damages for breach of contract and negligence. The two men pleaded the Statute of Limitations.
The High Court, with Kearns P. presiding, heard oral evidence and dismissed the claim. The plaintiffs appealed. In a judgment of 2 March 2016, the Court of Appeal (Ryan P, Irvine and Hogan JJ.) allowed that appeal and sent the case back to the High Court.
The Court of Appeal held that the foundations were defective in March 2004 but caused no damage until December 2005. It found the six-year limitation period had been counted from too early a point.
Mr Deane and Mr Lohan asked the Supreme Court to restore the High Court order. They argued that the Court of Appeal had in effect changed the law and had introduced uncertainty. Mr Brandley and his company opposed leave. They said the case turned on its own narrow facts.
The Supreme Court said the core of the application was when time runs in property damage claims. It was satisfied that the issue is a matter of general public importance. That meets the constitutional test for leave.
The appeal will cover three questions, subject to refinement at the case management list. Does time run from when the damage is manifest? Does it run from when the damage is discovered? Does it run from when the damage occurs?
The Court noted that a determination on leave decides that application only. The substantive appeal will deal with the issues in due course.