localnews.ie

Ciara Fusco granted Supreme Court appeal in Brendan Smyth abuse claim against Bishop of Kilmore

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear whether her claim was properly struck out on a preliminary issue, without oral evidence, because of a 1998 settlement in Northern Ireland.

The Supreme Court has granted Ciara Fusco leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision that struck out her claim against Leo O'Reilly, the Bishop of Kilmore. The determination was delivered on 15 March 2016.

Ms Fusco says she was sexually assaulted on a regular basis by Fr Brendan Smyth. She brought proceedings in Northern Ireland that were settled by an accord dated 9 April 1998, for £25,000 plus legal costs.

In 2012 she began fresh proceedings here. She claims a separate cause of action arose from the disclosure that the bishop's predecessor convened two meetings in March and April 1975, then knew of Fr Smyth's abuse of children but failed to act.

Kearns P. ruled in the High Court on 28 February 2014 that her claim was covered by the accord, and her case was struck out. The Court of Appeal dismissed her appeal on 12 November 2015.

Her application raises similar issues to those in appeals by Marie Cafolla and Mario Cafolla.

Bishop O'Reilly opposed leave. His side said the accord closed her claim completely. It was stated on his behalf that otherwise "no settlement of litigation would ever be truly final or conclusive".

The Supreme Court held an oral hearing. It said the use of preliminary issues in complex cases is a matter of general public importance.

The Supreme Court also ruled: "The issue of an accord and satisfaction, and the finality of litigation, is a matter of general public importance."

It granted leave on three issues. The first is whether the question should have been decided as a preliminary issue without oral evidence. The second is whether, if not, the case should go back to the High Court. The third is whether, if so, the Court of Appeal was right that she was bound by the accord.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal