The Supreme Court has refused Brendan McCleary and Brendan Hamilton leave to appeal in a costs dispute with Allied Irish Banks plc. The decision was delivered on 30 May 2016.
The two men had issued proceedings against the bank, claiming damages for deceit. They alleged that certain documents were forgeries. Two days later, the bank issued a summary summons claiming money due on a loan agreement.
On 12 March 2015, the bank applied to strike out its summary summons. It said it would pursue its claim as a counterclaim in the men's proceedings. The High Court made no order as to costs in the summary proceedings.
The Court of Appeal, on 29 February 2016, changed that order. It ruled that the summary summons costs would be costs in the cause of the counterclaim. If the men defeat the counterclaim, they will on the face of it be entitled to those costs.
The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal had applied established principles on costs. It said the men were wrong to believe they were automatically entitled to costs. It found no evidence for their claim of a tactical practice by banks, and no issue of general public importance.