The Supreme Court has refused Patrick Dorgan and 11 others leave to appeal. They practise as Coakley Moloney Solicitors. It decided on 30 May 2016.
They wanted to appeal a Court of Appeal judgment of 25 January 2016. The plaintiffs were Emerald Isle Assurances and Investments Limited, Timothy Maverley and James Morey.
The plaintiffs claimed against the solicitors over an earlier action against Hibernian. That action settled in July 2010 for €300,000, including costs. The claim against the solicitors is for the euro equivalent of IR£6.2m.
The High Court found a more elaborate warning would have made no difference. The Court of Appeal found Sylvester Duane negligent and allowed the appeal. It sent the case back for assessment of damages.
It said the Court of Appeal created no new duty of care or test of causation. Whether that court applied the test correctly was not a matter of general public importance.