localnews.ie

Ewaen Fred Ogieriakhi granted Supreme Court appeal in EU Directive case

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court set out five questions it will hear, including whether the State's honest misunderstanding of a Directive affects how serious the breach was.

The Supreme Court has granted Ewaen Fred Ogieriakhi leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision. It made the determination on 16 June 2016.

His case is against the Minister for Justice and Equality, Ireland, the Attorney General and An Post. He sought leave to appeal the whole Court of Appeal judgment of 26 February 2016. That court was made up of Ryan P, Peart J and Irvine J.

The Supreme Court will hear the appeal on five questions. They are subject to case management.

The first asks about State officials who honestly and excusably misunderstood a Directive. Is that a significant factor in deciding whether the breach was serious?

The second asks about a person who suffered damage because a Directive was incorrectly transposed in Ireland. Can that person claim damages under domestic law? Or are they confined to the criteria set by the Court of Justice of the European Union?

The third asks about a finding that the State's failure gave no damages under those criteria. Did that mean he had no right to damages under domestic law? That includes the Constitution.

The fourth asks whether he has any remedy under domestic law. It describes him as a person dismissed because of regulations that failed to implement the Directive properly.

The fifth asks about the duty to mitigate loss. Can it require someone in his position to accept an unwritten offer of employment?

The Court said a decision on leave settles only that application. It added that any issue raised will be resolved in its final decision.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal