localnews.ie

Alan O'Leary refused Supreme Court appeal over measles vaccine injury claim

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court declined to hear his appeal against the dismissal of his action against the Health Service Executive, Ireland, the Attorney General and Martin Healy.

The Supreme Court has refused Alan O'Leary leave to appeal in his claim that a measles vaccination at 15 months caused his severe brain damage. The decision was delivered on 10 May 2016.

Mr O'Leary sued through his sister and next friend, Charlene O'Leary. His defendants were the Health Service Executive, Ireland, the Attorney General and Martin Healy.

The High Court dismissed his action after he called two expert witnesses. On 10 February 2016, the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal. It found he had adduced no admissible evidence to support his case.

Mr O'Leary argued that the case raised matters of general public importance, including informed consent and compensation for vaccine injury. He also asked that Geoghegan v Harris be overruled.

The Supreme Court disagreed. It said the Court of Appeal had not laid down any rule excluding claims by people injured by vaccines.

It said Mr O'Leary had simply failed to produce admissible evidence of a legal wrong. The Court added that he had not identified why Geoghegan v Harris was wrong.

The Court said "no issue of general public importance has been identified".

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal