Paul Hegarty has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his negligence claim against Mercy University Hospital Cork Limited. The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 11 May 2016.
Mr Hegarty sued the hospital over the care he received there between 6 February and 5 April 2007. He claimed it was negligent in failing to communicate properly with him about an MRSA diagnosis and his progress, and about complications after his first operation.
Irvine J dismissed the claim in the High Court on 25 November 2011, finding he had been given all the relevant factual and clinical information. The Court of Appeal (Ryan P, Irvine and Hogan JJ) dismissed his appeal on 10 February 2016.
Mr Hegarty said the trial judge had relied on an unsworn assertion by the hospital's counsel, which he argued breached his right to a fair trial. The hospital said the case rested on findings of fact.
The Supreme Court said counsel's statement explained why certain questions had not been put to witnesses, and was not evidence. It found the trial judge had preferred the sworn evidence of the surgeon. It said the case stood on its facts.
The court was satisfied that no matter of general public importance arose, and that an appeal was not necessary in the interests of justice.