The Supreme Court has granted Marie Cafolla leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision that struck out her claim against Leo O'Reilly, the Bishop of Kilmore. The determination was delivered on 15 March 2016.
Ms Cafolla says she was sexually assaulted on a regular basis by Fr Brendan Smyth. She brought proceedings in Northern Ireland, and the court heard she settled them under an accord dated 5 October 1999 for £16,000 plus her legal costs.
In 2012 she began fresh proceedings here, claiming a separate cause of action. She alleges that two meetings were convened in March and April 1975 by the bishop's predecessor, who then knew of Fr Smyth's abuse of children but took no appropriate steps. The second defendant, Sean Brady, is not a party to this application.
On 21 October 2013 the High Court ordered a preliminary issue: whether her claim was already covered by an accord and satisfaction, meaning a settlement that closes a claim. Kearns P. found on 28 February 2014 that it was, and her case was struck out.
The Court of Appeal dismissed her appeal on 12 November 2015. Similar defences have been raised in claims by her brother Mario Cafolla and her cousin Ciara Fusco. Bishop O'Reilly opposed leave, saying the accord closed her claim.
The Supreme Court heard the parties orally. It said using the preliminary issue procedure in complex cases is a matter of general public importance, as are accord and satisfaction and the finality of litigation.
It granted leave on three issues. The first is whether the question should have been decided as a preliminary issue without oral evidence. The second is whether, if not, the case should go back to the High Court. The third is whether, if so, the Court of Appeal was right that she was bound by the accord.