localnews.ie

Gerry Walshe refused Supreme Court appeal over marriage equality referendum challenge

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court said he was trying to reopen a point already decided in earlier proceedings over the Thirty-fourth Amendment referendum certificate.

Gerry Walshe has been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court over a High Court refusal to let him seek judicial review of the Referendum Returning Officer. The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 5 May 2016.

Mr Walshe had already brought proceedings on the same point, and the High Court and Court of Appeal had refused them. The Supreme Court had also refused leave to appeal in those earlier proceedings, which challenged the marriage equality referendum.

This time he sought to appeal a decision of Heneghan J on 23 September 2015, refusing leave to begin judicial review proceedings against the returning officer. He represented himself. His respondents were Ireland, the Attorney General, the Referendum Returning Officer and the Referendum Commission.

Mr Walshe argued that the signing of the referendum certificate on 28 August 2015 was void. The State respondents said there were no exceptional circumstances and called the case a collateral attack on the validation of the referendum result.

The Supreme Court said the point had already been decided, and that raising it again in a different form did not change that. The proceedings were interlocutory, with very limited evidence and no full hearing. It added: "There must be an end to litigation."

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal