Eric Eoin Marques has been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court from the High Court in his case against the Attorney General. The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 3 May 2016.
Mr Marques sought to appeal a High Court decision delivered on 16 December 2015. The case concerned whether he would face a flagrant denial of justice in a trial and sentencing process in the United States if he were surrendered there.
The Attorney General opposed the application. The State said the High Court judge had applied the correct test and that his conclusions were specific to the facts. It also said no exceptional circumstances or urgency had been shown.
The Supreme Court noted that the High Court judge dealt with the issues in a single judgment of 127 pages, and that the large number of issues was a factor to consider.
It said Mr Marques had a choice to make. He has already appealed to the Court of Appeal, which will rehear the case in full. A Supreme Court appeal is limited to issues that meet the constitutional criteria.
The court refused leave for a direct appeal, saying the Court of Appeal should be his primary route. The refusal does not bar him from applying for leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal later.