localnews.ie

Motor Insurers' Bureau of Ireland granted Supreme Court appeal over Setanta claims

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will hear whether the MIBI Agreement makes the bureau liable for claims against drivers who were insured by the liquidated Setanta Insurance Company.

The Supreme Court has granted the Motor Insurers' Bureau of Ireland (MIBI) leave to appeal a Court of Appeal judgment about claims linked to the collapsed Setanta Insurance Company Ltd. The court gave its decision on 29 April 2016.

The issue is whether the MIBI must pay successful claims by plaintiffs who sued drivers formerly insured by Setanta. The determination puts the number of cases at around 1,750. Setanta went into liquidation following an Extraordinary General Meeting in Malta on 16 April 2014. The MIBI runs claims where an uninsured or untraced driver is involved in an accident, under an agreement with the Government. The scheme is funded by an annual levy on insurance companies.

The Law Society of Ireland advanced the claim in the High Court. Hedigan J held that where a driver was uninsured because the insurer collapsed, the MIBI had to take over the case in the usual way. The Court of Appeal upheld that on 2 March 2016. Ryan P, Finlay Geoghegan J and Hogan J each gave a separate judgment. Ryan P said the agreement "does mean what it appears to say". Finlay Geoghegan J proposed varying the High Court order so that only the first of two questions would be answered.

The MIBI argued that this kind of liability was never contemplated and would lead to unjustifiable calls on insurers through the annual levy. The Law Society opposed any further appeal, saying the case involved only ordinary principles of contract interpretation. The Accountant of the Courts of Justice, who brought the application under the Insurance Act 1964, stayed neutral.

The Supreme Court said the issue affects all insurance companies that underwrite road traffic insurance. It said the issue could also affect the cost of insurance to the public. It held that the impact of a decision can bear on whether a case is of general public importance. Leave was granted on three points. The first is whether the MIBI Agreement can be read to impose liability on insurers who are party to it for claims against Setanta-insured drivers. The second concerns the principles for construing the agreement, including the influence of statute. The third is how any liability would affect the High Court's power to approve payments from the Insurance Compensation Fund.

The points may be refined or altered at a case management conference. The court did not decide whether the MIBI is liable.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal