Conan Murphy has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against an order for his retrial. The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 25 April 2016.
The Court of Appeal (Birmingham, Sheehan and Edwards JJ) quashed his conviction on 6 November 2015 but ordered a retrial in the Special Criminal Court. He and his co-accused, Mr McKevitt, had been convicted of unlawful possession of an explosive substance.
The Special Criminal Court had reserved its judgment to 24 February 2012. On 23 February 2012 the Supreme Court delivered its Damache judgment, and the trial court refused to hear counsel on it the next day.
Mr Murphy said he spent approximately five months in custody awaiting trial. He said he spent a further approximately five months in custody after conviction, until the Court of Appeal granted bail, and then faced strict bail conditions.
He argued that a retrial would cause him significant personal prejudice. He also argued that, on the law as it stood at the time, he would have been acquitted.
The Supreme Court said it could not hold that the Damache decision would have decided the case, because other arguments had been made about the search and arrests. It was not satisfied that the interests of justice required leave.