The Supreme Court has granted Michael Murphy Jr and Michael Murphy Senior leave to appeal in a Proceeds of Crime case brought by the Criminal Assets Bureau. It gave its decision on 27 April 2016, and Amy Forrest is a notice party.
The case began after Michael Murphy Jr was found on 28 May 2009 in possession of firearms. Gardaí obtained a warrant under section 29 of the Offences Against the State Act 1939 to search his house in Cork, and found cash of €9,000 and STG£6,625. He was later convicted of firearms offences and sentenced to six years in prison. The Criminal Assets Bureau then obtained a temporary order under the Proceeds of Crime Act 1996 freezing the assets of both men.
The trial on whether certain assets were the proceeds of crime was delayed after the death of Feeney J. The point about the search warrant was then raised before Birmingham J in the High Court. On 7 November 2014, Birmingham J held that the rule excluding unconstitutionally obtained evidence, as it was then understood, did not apply. He made orders under section 3 of the 1996 Act, and the order was perfected on 25 November 2014.
The Court of Appeal upheld that on 18 February 2016, in a judgment of Peart J with Finlay Geoghegan and Irvine JJ agreeing. Peart J held that "the exclusionary rule is simply inapplicable to such applications." The Murphys said the issue had never been decided and would affect a whole class of cases. The Bureau argued the breach was accidental and unintentional, and that Michael Murphy Sr could not rely on the protection of a home that was not his.
The Supreme Court said whether a rule excluding illegally or unconstitutionally obtained evidence applies in civil proceedings is a matter of wide public importance. It noted that the High Court order bars both men from dealing with the property listed in it, including an Audi car, cash and Irish Life investment bonds.
Leave was granted on three questions, with the details to be worked out at a case management hearing. They concern whether evidence can be excluded where the dwelling entered is not that of the person relying on the right, and whether any rule requires exclusion of such evidence from civil proceedings, including those under the Proceeds of Crime Act.