The Supreme Court has granted Una Ruffley leave to appeal in her workplace bullying claim against the Board of Management of St Anne's School. It gave its decision on 27 April 2016.
Ms Ruffley was a special needs assistant in a school for children with physical and intellectual disabilities. She claimed damages for personal injuries, saying her employer was negligent and in breach of its duty of care. She said the way the school carried out a disciplinary process against her amounted to workplace bullying. The process began with an incident in September 2009 and ended in May 2010.
The High Court found her treatment throughout the process was inappropriate and persistent. It found it resulted in psychiatric injury to her, and it awarded her damages.
The Court of Appeal allowed the school's appeal on 8 December 2015, by a majority. Ryan P and Irvine J were in the majority, and Finlay Geoghegan J dissented. All three agreed she had been treated contrary to fair procedures. They also agreed that the finding of psychiatric injury could not be disturbed. The majority held that the case did not come within the definition of bullying.
Ms Ruffley asked the Supreme Court to decide three questions. The school opposed the application and said the Court of Appeal had applied an objective test. The Supreme Court refused leave on the first question, which was whether bullying is judged objectively or subjectively. It said the Court of Appeal had unanimously decided that in her favour.
The court granted leave on two questions. The first is whether an unfairly carried out disciplinary process that causes psychiatric injury can be actionable as workplace bullying without evidence of malicious intent by the employer. The second is whether behaviour not witnessed by other people in the workplace can undermine an employee's dignity. The court said both points could matter widely to employees and employers.