Mario Cafolla has been granted leave by the Supreme Court to appeal in a case concerning a prior settlement, in a determination dated 2016. The appeal concerns whether his claim against Leo O’Reilly was properly struck out after the settlement was treated as binding.
The determination says Cafolla’s proceedings arose from alleged sexual abuse by Fr Brendan Smyth between about 1968 and 1976. In 1996, he brought damages proceedings in Northern Ireland against several defendants. Those proceedings were settled in 1998 under an accord that recorded payment of £25,000, plus legal costs, in full and final settlement of claims connected with the complaints about Smyth.
Cafolla later brought fresh proceedings in Ireland, claiming a separate cause of action and further damage. He alleged that two meetings in 1975 had made O’Reilly’s predecessor, then Bishop of Kilmore, aware of abuse by Smyth, but that no appropriate steps were taken to prevent further abuse. O’Reilly is identified in the determination as the present Bishop of Kilmore.
The High Court directed a preliminary issue on whether Cafolla’s claim had already been resolved by accord and satisfaction. It found that it had and struck out the proceedings against O’Reilly. The Court of Appeal dismissed Cafolla’s appeal, concluding that the High Court was correct.
The Supreme Court has now granted leave to appeal on three issues. It will consider whether the settlement question should have been decided as a preliminary issue without oral evidence, and, if not, whether the matter should be sent back to the High Court. If that procedure was permissible, the appeal may also consider whether the Court of Appeal was right to uphold the finding that Cafolla was bound by the accord and that his proceedings should be struck out.
The determination says the questions about the use of preliminary issues in complex cases and the finality of settlements raise matters of general public importance. Granting leave permits an appeal to proceed; the determination does not decide those issues on their merits.