localnews.ie

Jerry Beades refused Supreme Court appeal over bid to block High Court president

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

Mr Beades had sought an injunction against the appointment of Mr Justice Peter Kelly, and wanted to appeal the High Court's refusal directly.

Jerry Beades has been refused a direct appeal to the Supreme Court. The court gave its decision on 19 April 2016.

Mr Beades, who represented himself, sued Ireland, the Attorney General, the Judicial Appointments Advisory Board and the Minister for Justice and Equality. He sought an interim injunction to stop the appointment of Mr Justice Peter Kelly as President of the High Court.

Gilligan J refused the injunction on 21 December 2015. He also refused the State's application to strike out the proceedings. The court said no serious issue to be tried had been made out.

Mr Beades asked to appeal straight to the Supreme Court. A direct appeal from the High Court is allowed only where there are exceptional circumstances. The matter must also raise a point of general public importance or the interests of justice.

The Supreme Court said his claims were bare assertions. The case was an application for an interim injunction, and no trial had taken place. It said there was no basis for a direct appeal.

The State defendants denied the allegations. They said the law Mr Beades relied on covers ordinary High Court judges, not the President.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal