Eoghan Breatnach has been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court. The decision was delivered on 10 May 2016.
He wanted to appeal a High Court decision of Hedigan J, delivered on 12 June 2015. It appears the High Court dismissed his appeal from the Circuit Court.
The Circuit Court had given Wynnefield House Management Limited judgment against him for service charges of €6,993.76. The company opposed the application.
A direct appeal from the High Court needs a point of general public importance, or the interests of justice. It also needs exceptional circumstances.
The Supreme Court said the case involved summary judgment on a sum found due. It raised no issue of law of general public importance.
The court said the interests of justice did not require an appeal and there were no exceptional circumstances. It did not need to decide the company's argument under the 1936 and 1961 Acts.