Joseph Delaney has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his negligence claim against Allied Irish Banks plc. The decision was delivered on 18 March 2016.
Mr Delaney had €346,000 withdrawn from an account at AIB in Edenderry, County Offaly, between 20 August and 15 September 2008. It was paid out in six bank drafts, and the accountant Gerard Killaly lodged some into his own account.
In July 2009, AIB obtained a judgment of €15.5m against Mr Killaly. He and his wife were declared bankrupt shortly afterwards, and Mr Delaney was left without his money or security.
Mr Delaney argued that the bank owed him a duty as a customer to warn him of Mr Killaly's financial position and to stop the transfers. The receivers Declan Taite and Sharon Barrett, appointed by NAMA, were also respondents.
Cregan J in the High Court dismissed the claim as unstateable and bound to fail. The Court of Appeal upheld that in a judgment of Peart J on 28 January 2016, finding no such duty of care.
The Supreme Court said the legal principles applied were well established, and it was impossible to see how Mr Delaney could meet the constitutional criteria for a further appeal. He had already used his right to one appeal.