The Supreme Court refused Nehaal Singh leave to appeal in a case brought by Costello Transport Limited, in a decision of 8 March 2016. Mr Singh, who acted for himself, had been liquidator of Kelly Trucks Limited.
He had been appointed in January 2014, on the nomination of the company's directors, James Kelly and Anne Kelly. Costello Transport, a judgment creditor, was dissatisfied with him and applied to have him removed. On 17 February 2014 the High Court (Baker J.) removed him and appointed Gerard Murphy in his place.
In April 2015 the High Court corrected two errors in that order. It had named the wrong judicial officer and cited the wrong section of the Companies Act 1963. Mr Singh appealed. The Court of Appeal heard Costello Transport's motion to strike the appeal out on 19 October 2015.
It found that Mr Singh had not come before the court on three occasions. Mrs Kelly had tried to prosecute the appeal for him although she is not a solicitor. The court held she had no right to do so and that her claimed assignment of the appeal was void. It struck out the appeal and ordered costs against Mr Singh and Mrs Kelly jointly.
The Supreme Court said Mr Singh had not given reasons that met the constitutional test. It said nothing suggested the Court of Appeal had misapplied well-established principles. It also said he could not seek to quash High Court orders in this application.