The Supreme Court granted Anthony Murphy and Joseph Carberry leave to appeal on 4 March 2016. Both are challenging the legality of their detention. Both pleaded guilty to possession of a controlled drug for sale or supply. Mr Murphy admitted having synthetic cannabinoids worth €13,000 or more at Carnlough Road, Cabra, Dublin, on 6 February 2011. The Circuit Court sentenced him to eight years, with the last three suspended. Mr Carberry's case involved a substance called Pentedrone. Neither man appealed.
Their cases followed Bederev v. Ireland. On 10 March 2015 the Court of Appeal held section 2(2) of the Misuse of Drugs Act 1977 invalid. It said the section gave the government law-making powers. It also held the 2010 order declaring controlled drugs invalid.
Both men said this made the orders covering their substances invalid. They asked the High Court for release under Article 40.4.2 of the Constitution. The President of the High Court refused on 24 April 2015. On 16 November 2015 the Court of Appeal upheld that decision. It relied on an earlier Supreme Court case, A v. Governor of Arbour Hill Prison.
The State opposed leave. It said both men pleaded guilty with legal advice and did not challenge the law. It said Mr Murphy had already sought to challenge his detention twice.
The Supreme Court said the case raises matters of general public importance. It listed four questions. One is whether Bederev was correctly decided. Another is whether it had retrospective effect that would invalidate the convictions. The court also asked whether the men fall within any exception to the rule in the Arbour Hill case. Its final question is whether a Court of Appeal declaration, itself under appeal, can invalidate their convictions retrospectively.
The court directed early case management. This takes account of the Bederev appeal, listed for 12 April.