localnews.ie

Patrick Vesey refused Supreme Court appeal on evidence

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had ruled that correspondence he wanted to rely on could not be put before it in his negligence case against solicitors.

The Supreme Court refused Patrick Vesey leave to appeal on 26 February 2016. He had sued solicitors Fabian Cadden & Company.

Mr Vesey claimed professional negligence and breach of contract. His claim concerned how the firm handled his personal injuries action against Bus Éireann. The High Court dismissed his claim on 14 April 2015.

He appealed to the Court of Appeal. At a directions hearing on 18 December 2015, Justice Finlay Geoghegan excluded some of his documents. They were letters written after the High Court hearing in October 2014. They were exchanged with an orthopaedic surgeon, his solicitor at the time and his barrister.

Mr Vesey wanted to appeal that ruling. He said the letters were vital and went to his honesty. The solicitors said the point did not meet the test for leave.

The Supreme Court said the ruling did not depart from established principles. It said leave is not ordinarily given on case management matters. It found no exceptional circumstances. It said nothing in his papers met the constitutional test. Leave was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal