localnews.ie

Joe Heffernan granted Supreme Court appeal over murder conviction and diminished responsibility

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal will test how the burden and standard of proof work when a defendant raises diminished responsibility under the Criminal Law (Insanity) Act 2006.

The Supreme Court on 26 February 2016 granted Joe Heffernan leave to appeal his murder conviction. He was convicted of murder at the Central Criminal Court. It was not disputed at his trial that he had unlawfully caused the death of the deceased.

The main issue at trial was his mental state. He argued that he had a mental disorder that substantially reduced his responsibility. If accepted, that defence under section 6 of the Criminal Law (Insanity) Act 2006 would have meant a verdict of manslaughter. The jury convicted him of murder.

Mr Heffernan appealed to the Court of Appeal. He said the trial judge had wrongly directed the jury on the burden and standard of proof for diminished responsibility. The Court of Appeal gave its judgment on 21 December 2015. It held that the 2006 Act did not change the earlier common law position, so the jury had been directed correctly. It dismissed his appeal.

Mr Heffernan then applied to the Supreme Court. He said the question would affect anyone who raises diminished responsibility in future. The Director of Public Prosecutions said the Court of Appeal was right and agreed that the 2006 Act did not alter the old rules.

The Supreme Court said the point is general and of public importance. It concerns whether the 2006 Act changed the traditional rule that the burden of proof on insanity issues rests on the accused. It also concerns whether the standard of proof was affected. The court said the answer could affect the basis on which people are convicted of serious offences, and that it applies to any accused who raises the defence.

The court also found that Mr Heffernan had a reasonable possibility of success. It said the Director's response had simply asserted that the Court of Appeal was right, which did not address the test for leave. Leave was granted on one ground. That ground is whether the Court of Appeal was incorrect in how it interpreted the burden and standard of proof under section 6, and, if so, what follows for this case. The appeal itself has yet to be decided.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal