localnews.ie

Edel Grace and Peter Sweetman granted Supreme Court appeal over Tipperary wind farm permission

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The applicants are allowed to appeal directly from the High Court on standing and on whether a refusal of leave to appeal can itself be challenged.

The Supreme Court has granted Edel Grace and Peter Sweetman leave to appeal directly from the High Court in their challenge to planning permission for a wind farm at Keeper Hill, Co. Tipperary. The determination was made on 26 February 2016.

The applicants are seeking to quash the decision of An Bord Pleanála of 22 July 2014 to grant permission for the Bunkimalta Windfarm, a proposed development of 16 wind turbines. They also want declarations that the assessment carried out before permission was granted was inadequate. ESB Wind Development Limited and Coillte are notice parties.

The High Court, in judgments of 1 October 2015 and 4 December 2015, held that the assessment was valid. It also held that the applicants lacked sufficient interest to bring the case, mainly because they had not raised the issues at the hearings before the Board. The High Court then refused a certificate allowing an appeal to the Court of Appeal and declined to refer a question to the Court of Justice of the European Union.

Because they were seeking to bypass the Court of Appeal, the applicants had to show exceptional circumstances warranting a direct appeal. The Board and the developers opposed. They said the law on appealing a refusal of leave was well settled and that standing no longer mattered, since the High Court went on to decide the merits.

The Supreme Court did not accept that. It said it is arguable that its case law on standing in environmental matters may need revising in light of recent Court of Justice decisions, and that this is a matter of general public importance. It also said that, with an appeal blocked without a High Court certificate, the exceptional circumstances for a direct appeal could well be met.

The Court added that its earlier refusal of leave in another wind farm case, People Over Wind, did not govern this one, because the legal issues were very different. Leave was granted on three points. The first is whether the Supreme Court's case law on environmental standing must be revised. The second is whether there can be an appeal against a High Court refusal of leave to appeal in environmental matters, given the 33rd Amendment and European law. The third is whether the substantive appeal should be allowed, if that proves necessary.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal