The Supreme Court has granted Martin McDonagh leave to appeal a Court of Appeal ruling in his libel action against Sunday Newspapers Limited, publisher of the Sunday World. The determination was made on 18 February 2016. In the High Court a jury awarded Mr McDonagh €900,000 in damages over articles alleging he was a drug dealer and a loan shark. The jury found that the newspaper had not proved either allegation. It did find that the newspaper had proved he was a tax evader and a criminal.
The newspaper appealed. In a judgment of 19 October 2015, delivered by Justice Hogan for a court that also included Justice Kelly and Justice Irvine, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal on the drug dealing allegation and dismissed that part of the claim entirely. It said the media's constitutional right to publish true material could not be overridden by a jury verdict.
On the loan sharking allegation, the Court of Appeal sent the claim back to the High Court for a retrial. It said the jury should have been warned that Mr McDonagh's credibility had been compromised. It also ordered him to repay €90,000 paid out under the High Court order.
Mr McDonagh argued that the ruling undermined the role of juries in libel cases and that the Court of Appeal had misapplied the rule in Hay v. O'Grady. The newspaper said the Court of Appeal had simply applied established law, including the rule in Browne v. Dunn, and that he disagreed with the outcome.
The Supreme Court granted leave on five issues. They include whether the Court of Appeal can reverse a jury verdict on defamation where there is strong evidence the allegation was true, and whether the media's constitutional right to publish cannot be compromised by a jury verdict. They also cover whether the jury had to be warned about Mr McDonagh's credibility and when a verdict can be reversed as perverse. The last is the present status of the rule in Browne v. Dunn.
The court stressed that granting leave is not a finding that the Court of Appeal made an error.