The Supreme Court has granted Thomas Joseph O'Connor leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision in his European arrest warrant case against the Minister for Justice and Equality. The decision was delivered on 16 February 2016.
Two sets of proceedings were heard together. In the first, the Minister sought an order for Mr O'Connor's surrender under section 16 of the European Arrest Warrant Act 2003. In the second, Mr O'Connor challenged the constitutionality of the Act, arguing that the legal basis of the legal aid or representation scheme for people facing surrender was inadequate.
In the High Court, Justice Edwards ruled against Mr O'Connor in both cases and made the surrender order. On 23 October 2015 the Court of Appeal, with Justice Ryan and Justice Irvine in the majority, upheld those conclusions. Justice Hogan agreed that no EU legal right had been breached, but dissented on the constitutional question.
Justice Hogan found that a person facing surrender to the International Criminal Court has statutory legal aid, while a person facing surrender under the 2003 Act has only an administrative scheme. He would have declared this a breach of equality before the law under Article 40.1 of the Constitution.
The Supreme Court said that in light of the dissenting judgment "it would be impossible to say that there are not arguments both ways on the equality issue". It added that the issue would apply to anyone facing surrender under the 2003 Act, so it meets the constitutional threshold. It said it expressed no view on the merits.
It also gave leave on a second ground, whether a question of European law should be referred to the Court of Justice. That question concerns legal representation in surrender cases being provided through an administrative scheme rather than a statutory one. The court said it could not rule out a realistic possibility that a reference would be needed, though that does not mean one will follow. Leave was refused on Mr O'Connor's attempt to revisit the Supreme Court's earlier decision in Olsson. Leave covers only the two grounds set out in the determination.