The Supreme Court has granted Patrick Kelly leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision in his freedom of information case against the Information Commissioner. The determination was made on 12 February 2016.
Mr Kelly brought the application himself. The case arises from a review the Commissioner began under section 34 of the Freedom of Information Act 1997. On 11 September 2013 the Commissioner discontinued that review on the basis that the application was vexatious.
Mr Kelly tried to appeal that decision to the High Court under section 42(1) of the Act. On 30 November 2015 the Court of Appeal held that he was not entitled to do so. It found that such an appeal lies only after a review has been carried out, and that the review here had been discontinued. The Court of Appeal judges were Justice Ryan, Justice Kelly and Justice Hogan.
Mr Kelly argued that the ruling raised a point of general public importance, because it concerns the right of members of the public to appeal decisions of the Information Commissioner. The Commissioner opposed leave, calling it a private matter and saying the case differed from Nowak v Data Protection Commissioner, where leave had been granted.
The Supreme Court said it is not a court of error correction. It accepted that two issues met the constitutional test. The first is whether an appeal lay to the High Court under section 42(1) of the 1997 Act against the decision to discontinue the review. The second is whether a similar issue arises under the Freedom of Information Act 2014.
Leave was granted on those two issues only. The court found that nothing else in Mr Kelly's application met the constitutional requirements, including his points about the affidavits and the Commissioner's handling of University College Dublin's submissions. The court also said the appeal should follow on from, and be heard by the same formation as, the Nowak appeal.