The Supreme Court has granted Martin Murray leave to appeal a Court of Appeal ruling that threw out his negligence claim against the solicitors who defended him in a criminal trial. The determination was made on 8 February 2016.
Mr Murray was charged with possession of heroin with intent to supply and was defended by Conan P. Budds and the Hanahoe solicitors' firm at Naas Circuit Criminal Court. He was convicted on 11 February 1999 and received a seven-year sentence. He lost two appeals against conviction in the Court of Criminal Appeal.
He then sued the solicitors by plenary summons issued on 2 February 2005. His amended claim sought damages for the worry and stress he said he suffered between 3 and 10 February 1999, facing an imminent trial without knowing who his counsel would be. The High Court (Clark J.) allowed that amendment.
The solicitors appealed. On 19 November 2015 the Court of Appeal allowed their appeal and dismissed the proceedings. It held the claim was a personal injury claim issued more than three years after the cause of action arose, so it was statute-barred. It added that damages are not recoverable for mental distress, stress and worry short of a recognised psychiatric illness.
Mr Murray asked the Supreme Court for leave on two grounds. The solicitors opposed, saying the facts were highly unusual and that the case turned on established law about limitation periods and damages for stress. The Supreme Court said Mr Murray had raised an issue of general public importance. That issue is whether a professional negligence claim, where the loss claimed is worry and stress short of a recognised physical injury, should be treated as a personal injury action under the shorter limitation period. Leave was granted on that issue alone.
The Court refused to consider his second ground, on whether a written report from an independent expert must be obtained before professional negligence proceedings begin. It said the issue did not arise, as the Court of Appeal made no order on that appeal and so no appeal could lie.