localnews.ie

Leopardstown Club granted Supreme Court appeal in tennis courts cable dispute

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear Leopardstown Club's challenge to a Court of Appeal order sending a misrepresentation claim by Templeville Developments and Philip Smith back for retrial.

The Supreme Court has granted Leopardstown Club Limited leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision in its dispute with Templeville Developments Limited and Philip Smith. The determination was made on 9 February 2016. The dispute centres on a Mediated Settlement Agreement and the intended site of seven tennis courts, to be built by Templeville and Mr Smith at Leopardstown Racecourse. A transverse cable crossed that site.

Templeville and Mr Smith counterclaimed that the agreement should be rescinded because Leopardstown had misrepresented the position. In the High Court, Justice Charleton dismissed that counterclaim. He held that they had actual knowledge of the cable.

They appealed. On 26 July 2015 the Court of Appeal, in judgments from Justice Finlay Geoghegan and Justice Hogan, found that Justice Charleton had misdirected himself in law and on the facts. It held that Leopardstown had not shown actual knowledge of the cable, and that constructive knowledge was not enough to defeat the counterclaim.

The Court of Appeal upheld their appeal on that point. It sent the single issue of Leopardstown's alleged misrepresentation back to the High Court for a retrial before a different judge.

Leopardstown then asked the Supreme Court for leave to appeal the whole decision. It argued that the Court of Appeal had misapplied the rule in Hay v. O'Grady on findings of fact made by a trial judge, and misapplied the law on misrepresentation in Gahan v. Boland. Templeville and Mr Smith said the Court of Appeal had applied both correctly.

The Supreme Court decided that the issues are matters of general public importance and that the interests of justice require an appeal. It said it was not prejudging the outcome. It also said the status of a trial judge's explicit and implied findings of fact is fundamental to the role of appeal courts. On misrepresentation, it said the law should be reviewed, and if necessary clarified. That includes whether constructive knowledge can be a defence.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal