The Supreme Court refused Mary Healy leave to appeal on 8 March 2016. She had sued Dr Brendan Buckley, the Bon Secours Hospital and the Bon Secours Health System for medical negligence.
Her action, begun in 2004, concerned her treatment with the drug Sandostatin LAR between September 2000 and March 2001. She claimed negligence and said her consent to the treatment was not properly informed.
The High Court rejected the claim in a judgment of 20 May 2010. It found no negligence by any of the respondents and held that her consent was valid.
Mrs Healy appealed. On 17 November 2015 the Court of Appeal upheld the High Court. It said it was bound by findings of fact that were supported by credible evidence. She then asked the Supreme Court for leave to bring a further appeal. Dr Buckley and the hospital opposed.
The Supreme Court gave two reasons for refusing. Her first argument was based on facts specific to her case. Her second, that the Court of Appeal had made a new departure on informed consent, was "simply incorrect", because both courts applied well-settled principles.
It also said the interests of justice did not require a further appeal. The case ends there.