localnews.ie

Samuel Butler refused Supreme Court appeal in solicitors' unpaid fees case

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

Mr Butler, who represents himself, wanted discovery of documents he said he needed to defend a claim by Dundon Callanan Solicitors for unpaid fees.

The Supreme Court has refused Samuel Butler leave to appeal in a dispute with Dundon Callanan Solicitors, in a determination delivered on 22 January 2016. He acts for himself.

The solicitors, Maeve Callanan, Glenn Cooper and St John Dundon, are suing to recover unpaid fees for successfully defending him in Commercial Court proceedings. Mr Butler asked the High Court for discovery of certain documents, which he said were relevant to his defence.

On 16 February 2015 Justice Hedigan refused discovery in two of the categories he sought. He allowed discovery in a third category, with the documents to be produced for inspection.

Mr Butler appealed to the Court of Appeal over the categories he lost, and the solicitors cross-appealed on costs. On 4 November 2015 the Court of Appeal dismissed both appeals. It ordered Mr Butler to pay the costs of the appeal, with that order stayed until the High Court proceedings are decided.

He then applied to the Supreme Court. He argued that the documents were relevant and that the interests of justice required an appeal. The solicitors said the case was a private dispute over unpaid fees and that he had already had two hearings.

The Supreme Court found no issue of general public importance. It said the law on discovery was clear and that both courts had considered the relevance of the documents, which was largely a matter of fact. The application did not meet the constitutional threshold, and leave was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal