The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Gary Campion against the Court of Appeal's decision to uphold his murder conviction, but only on four certified points of law. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 7 December 2016.
Mr Campion applied for leave to appeal against the Court of Appeal's order and judgment of 31 July 2015, which upheld his conviction. His core complaint concerned the evidence of the principal witness for the prosecution.
The Supreme Court did not accept all of his grounds. It said the refusal of the trial judge to grant a direction at the end of the prosecution case did not raise a point of law of general public importance, because the principles are well settled. It said the same of a reference in the Court of Appeal's judgment to Mr Campion's eyebrows, which it described as entirely case-specific. It also said his first notice of application was seriously deficient and allowed him to file an amended one, which it described as deeply unsatisfactory.
However, the Supreme Court found it was in the interests of justice, and that a matter of general public importance arose, in relation to the procedure to be followed where there is material suggesting a significant witness may not be mentally competent, or that mental illness may affect the reliability of that witness's testimony, and the role of psychiatric evidence on that issue. It noted the Court of Appeal's view that the scope for expert evidence on whether a witness is reliable will be very limited.
Because it was not satisfied that the issue had been adequately set out in the application, the Supreme Court framed the points itself. They ask whether expert evidence is admissible on a witness's competence and credibility where there is a real possibility that mental illness affects reliability. They ask whether a trial judge should stop the trial if the witness refuses or is unable to be examined, and, if not, whether that is a factor in deciding an application for a direction. The final question is whether, where no expert evidence was called, an appeal court can review the trial judge's decision to let the case go to the jury on the basis of its own assessment of the witness's reliability.
Leave to appeal is limited to those certified points.