Anthony McGrath, who is suing through his wife and next friend Angela McGrath, has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his case against surgeon Brian Whooley and the Bon Secours Hospital. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 7 December 2016.
Mr McGrath's claim concerns an endoscope procedure on 18 September 2012, during which his bowel was punctured. It is claimed that the procedure was not negligently carried out, but that consent was compromised by a lack of warnings, and that no warning was given in aftercare about the risk of infection. The infection spread and became meningitis by 28 September, and Mr McGrath is now seriously and irreversibly brain damaged.
On 17 October 2016 the Court of Appeal (Ryan P., Irvine and Hanna JJ.) dismissed his appeal from a High Court ruling by Barr J. The High Court had refused to confine the defendants to the particulars they had given and to bar evidence outside them at trial. Mr McGrath argued that he needed a fixed set of facts to avoid being "ambushed" at the hearing and that his constitutional rights were breached.
The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal's judgment was an interlocutory ruling designed to facilitate a trial, and that both courts had applied standard law. It said reasonable notice of facts is required, but not that pleadings or particulars set out the case in evidential terms. The application met neither constitutional criterion and leave was refused.