The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by the law firm LK Shields against a professional negligence award of more than €11 million to Rosbeg Partners. The Supreme Court delivered its determination granting the firm leave to appeal on 22 November 2016.
LK Shields acted for Rosbeg Partners when it bought property in 1994. The firm did not complete the registration of the company's title in the Land Registry, and its file was inactive from March 2000 until September 2007. It is not disputed that this failure was negligent, so the dispute was over damages, in particular causation and mitigation of loss.
In late 2007 Rosbeg Partners received an offer of €10 million for the property from an adjoining landowner, subject to contract and confirmation of the site area. That did not proceed while the company worked to regularise the registration, and in a falling property market later offers of €8 million and €6 million were not accepted. By the time of the High Court hearing, the land was valued at €1.5 million.
The High Court (Peart J.) found that Rosbeg Partners had acted reasonably in not accepting the later offers. It awarded €8.5 million, being the difference between the €10 million offer and the €1.5 million value, plus increased interest charges and increased capital gains tax liability, bringing the total above €11 million. The Court of Appeal (MacMenamin J., with Finlay Geoghegan and Irvine JJ. concurring) dismissed the firm's appeal in June 2016. It applied the Supreme Court's decision in Hay v O'Grady on appeals from findings and inferences made by a trial judge.
LK Shields argued that the Court of Appeal failed to distinguish between findings of fact and inferences of fact, and that causation and mitigation should be assessed objectively. Rosbeg Partners said contributory negligence had never been pleaded and that the appeal was purely about facts.
The Supreme Court said parts of the application were unsatisfactory, but granted leave because the award is very substantial and the case raises important issues on the assessment of damages and the test for appellate review. It noted that it had recently granted leave in another case on the same principles. Leave was granted on four grounds, including whether the Court of Appeal applied too low a standard of review of the trial court's inferences, and whether the High Court assessed damages correctly.