John Dundon has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against his conviction for threatening to kill. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 21 November 2016.
Mr Dundon was convicted by the Special Criminal Court of threatening to kill, contrary to section 5 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997. The Court of Appeal (Birmingham, Mahon and Edwards JJ.) dismissed his appeal on 30 May 2016. Identification evidence was central to the prosecution case. He had argued that the Special Criminal Court's ruling did not expressly say its members had reminded themselves of the caution needed with such evidence.
Mr Dundon asked the Supreme Court to hear the case, saying it raised an issue of general public importance: how a court sitting without a jury must deal with the warning that applies to visual identification evidence. The Director of Public Prosecutions said no such issue arose and that his argument would in effect require experienced judges to warn themselves.
The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal's reasoning was that there was evidence on which the Special Criminal Court could find the case proven, which is a question that arises in almost every criminal trial. It said it was not satisfied there was any arguable basis for the proposition that professional judges must warn themselves about identification evidence or show in each ruling that they applied every element of the law. Leave was refused.