Mary Anne Stephens has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in her case against Allianz plc. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 17 November 2016.
The proceedings began in the Circuit Court for the Western Circuit, County Mayo, where an order was made on 13 February 2013. Ms Stephens appealed to the High Court on Circuit, which heard the matter on 15 July 2013. Dissatisfied with that hearing, she tried to appeal to the Court of Appeal. On 25 January 2016 the Court of Appeal (Ryan P., Irvine and Mahon JJ.) struck out the appeal, saying it had no jurisdiction to hear it.
Ms Stephens asked the Supreme Court for leave, arguing that the Court of Appeal had barred her from challenging the High Court on Circuit hearing. She contended that a fundamental breach of fair procedures had occurred and that the Supreme Court had a duty to protect constitutional rights even where an order appears final. Allianz said no appeal lay from a High Court decision on a Circuit Court appeal, and so none lay to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court pointed to section 39 of the Courts of Justice Act 1936, which says such a High Court decision is "final and conclusive and not appealable". It said the Court of Appeal had applied a longstanding provision and well-established principles, so Ms Stephens could not meet the constitutional threshold for an appeal. Leave was refused.