localnews.ie

Wayne Dundon refused Supreme Court appeal over threats and witness intimidation convictions

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court described the application as a challenge to how the Court of Appeal applied established tests on new evidence, not a point of general public importance.

Wayne Dundon has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over the Court of Appeal's refusal to let him introduce new evidence in his appeal against his convictions for threats and witness intimidation. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 17 November 2016.

Mr Dundon was convicted by the Special Criminal Court on 16 March 2012 of threatening to kill or cause serious injury to the two sons of Alice Collins, and of intimidating a potential witness in criminal proceedings. In his appeal, he asked the Court of Appeal to admit prison phone-call transcripts and to argue additional grounds. The Court of Appeal (Birmingham, Mahon and Edwards JJ.) refused on 30 May 2016, finding the threshold for admitting new evidence had not been met.

Mr Dundon argued that the case raised a point of law of general public importance about that threshold. The Director of Public Prosecutions said the application raised no point of law and was an attempt to reach a different result on the same principles.

The Supreme Court agreed with the Director. It said the application was based on a specific set of facts and was in substance a "dressed up" appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision. It found the Court of Appeal had applied established tests and held that no issue of general public importance arose and that the interests of justice did not require an appeal.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal