localnews.ie

Permanent TSB granted Supreme Court appeal in David Langan property possession case

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will examine a Court of Appeal ruling on the Circuit Court's power to make possession orders over homes that have no rateable valuation.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Permanent TSB Plc in its property possession case against David Langan. The Supreme Court delivered its determination granting the bank leave to appeal on 17 November 2016.

On 23 February 2015 the Circuit Court in Dublin ordered that the bank recover six Dublin properties from Mr Langan, one in one set of proceedings and five in another. Mr Langan appealed to the High Court, where Baker J. sent five questions to the Court of Appeal in a case stated, at his request. They concerned the Circuit Court's jurisdiction where a property has no rateable valuation.

On 28 July 2016 the Court of Appeal (Ryan P., Irvine J. and Hogan J.) answered those questions. It held that, where a defendant puts the Circuit Court's jurisdiction in issue, that court cannot proceed to judgment on a domestic dwelling made unrateable by the Valuation Act 2001, unless the case falls within Part 10 of the Land and Conveyancing Law Reform Act 2009 or section 3 of the Land and Conveyancing Law Reform Act 2013.

The bank argued that the ruling raised a matter of general public importance. It pointed to the Court of Appeal's own remark that its conclusions were likely to have consequences that were "unfortunate and unintended", including additional costs for litigants and reduced access to local courts. It said the Court of Appeal's reading of the "local and limited jurisdiction" of the courts in Article 34 of the Constitution could have wide implications for the Circuit Court. It argued that the earlier Supreme Court decision in Grimes v. Owners of SS Bangor Bay had been misapplied or should be overruled.

Mr Langan did not oppose leave, according to the Supreme Court's understanding, though he maintained the Court of Appeal was correct. The Supreme Court said the bank had shown a matter of general public importance and that it could not be said the bank had no reasonable possibility of success. Leave was granted on the question of whether the Court of Appeal was wrong in its answers to each of the questions in the case stated and, if so, what follows for this case.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal