The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Sunday Newspapers Limited, Colm MacGinty and Nicola Tallant in the defamation action brought against them by Patrick Benedict Gilchrist. The Supreme Court delivered its written determination granting leave on 17 November 2016, having decided to grant leave on 1 November 2016.
Mr Gilchrist's High Court action was listed before a judge and jury on 3 November 2016, to follow a similar case brought by Isabel Rogers. The Commissioner of An Garda Síochána applied to be joined as a notice party and asked for the case to be heard otherwise than in public. The High Court (Mac Eochaidh J.) refused to join the Commissioner on 15 June 2016 and did not order a private hearing.
The Court of Appeal (Ryan P., Birmingham and Sheehan JJ.) set that decision aside on 21 October 2016. It joined the Commissioner as a notice party and ordered that the action be heard otherwise than in public, excluding the public and the media, with judgment to be given in open court. The Supreme Court is dealing with the Rogers case in a separate determination.
The defendants told the Supreme Court that the ruling concerns Article 34.1 of the Constitution, which requires justice to be administered in public. They argued that the Court of Appeal stretched an earlier Supreme Court decision, Irish Times Limited v. Ireland, and that the Commissioner is not a party to the action. They asked the court to distinguish that decision or depart from it.
The plaintiff opposed leave, but said the main concern was to keep the 3 November hearing date. The plaintiff backed the Commissioner's application in the Court of Appeal after the Commissioner indicated that the Official Secrets Act 1963 would otherwise prevent the plaintiff giving evidence. The Commissioner argued that the Court of Appeal had applied a well-established principle: that public justice must be weighed against other constitutional rights.
The Supreme Court found the decision was not a straightforward application of settled principles. It noted that the Commissioner invoked the 1963 Act against the parties, that the application came from a non-party, and that the case is civil rather than criminal. Leave was granted on two grounds: whether the Court of Appeal erred in balancing the public-justice requirement against other rights, and whether the measures it adopted were appropriate. A separate order stayed the High Court hearing pending the appeal.