localnews.ie

Sunday Newspapers granted Supreme Court appeal in Isabel Rogers defamation case

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear a challenge to a Court of Appeal order that the defamation action be heard otherwise than in public at the Garda Commissioner's request.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Sunday Newspapers Limited, Colm MacGinty and Nicola Tallant in the defamation case brought against them by Isabel Rogers. The Supreme Court delivered its written determination granting leave on 17 November 2016. It had decided to grant leave on 1 November 2016.

Ms Rogers's High Court action was listed for hearing before a judge and jury on 3 November 2016. The Commissioner of An Garda Síochána applied to be joined to the proceedings as a notice party and asked that the case be heard otherwise than in public. On 15 June 2016 the High Court (Mac Eochaidh J.) refused to join the Commissioner and did not order a hearing otherwise than in public.

The Court of Appeal (Ryan P., Birmingham and Sheehan JJ.) reversed that decision on 21 October 2016. It ordered that the Commissioner be joined and that the action be heard otherwise than in public, with members of the public and the media excluded and judgment to be handed down in open court. The same judgment dealt with a similar appeal in proceedings brought by Patrick Benedict Gilchrist, which the Supreme Court is considering in a separate determination.

The defendants argued that the decision raised a fundamental question about Article 34.1 of the Constitution, which requires justice to be administered in public. They said the Court of Appeal had expanded an earlier Supreme Court decision, Irish Times Limited v. Ireland, and that the Commissioner is not a party to the action. The plaintiff's position shifted during the Court of Appeal hearing: after the Commissioner indicated that, without a private hearing, the Official Secrets Act 1963 would bar the plaintiff from giving evidence, the plaintiff supported the Commissioner's application. The Commissioner said the Court of Appeal had applied well-established principles.

The Supreme Court said the case was not simply an application of settled principles. It pointed to three unusual features: the Commissioner relied on the 1963 Act against the parties, the request came from someone who is not a party, and the case is a civil one rather than a criminal one.

Leave was granted on two grounds: whether the Court of Appeal erred in balancing the constitutional requirement of public justice against the other rights asserted, and whether the measures it adopted were appropriate. A separate order stayed the hearing of the High Court action pending the appeal.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal