Sarah Comiskey has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in her challenge to a reference to her in an Employment Appeals Tribunal determination. The Supreme Court delivered its decision on 17 November 2016.
The reference appeared in a tribunal decision dated 12 February 2015 in an unfair dismissal claim brought by Cathy Shevlin against Sean Conlan, who was then a TD. Ms Comiskey was not a party to that claim and did not give evidence. She sought judicial review, saying the wording harmed her good name and her career as a barrister. The High Court (O'Malley J.) dismissed her application on the basis that she lacked standing to challenge a finding in a case to which she was not a party.
The Court of Appeal (Ryan P., MacMenamin and Finlay Geoghegan JJ.) dismissed her appeal on 18 July 2016. It found there was no adverse finding against her in the tribunal's determination.
Ms Comiskey asked the Supreme Court to take the case, arguing that it raised a matter of general public importance about whether private individuals can challenge such findings. The tribunal and Ms Shevlin did not oppose the application.
The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal's judgments made clear the reference could not bear the meaning she alleged, and that her reputation remained intact. With the factual basis of the case gone, it said there was no point continuing the litigation, and it refused leave.