localnews.ie

Joseph Lavery refused Supreme Court appeals over District Court judges and High Court rulings

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

Lavery's three applications for direct appeals from the High Court failed, and he has been ordered to pay the respondents' costs unless he makes written submissions.

The Supreme Court refused Joseph Lavery leave to appeal in three applications, in determinations delivered on 11 November 2016. He sought to appeal directly from the High Court, bypassing the Court of Appeal.

The first application concerned a ruling of Kelly P. on 29 April 2016. Mr Lavery had asked the High Court, without notice to the other side, to set aside orders made by two other High Court judges. The President refused, saying one High Court judge does not sit on appeal over another's orders. The respondent was District Judge Sean McBride, now retired.

The second and third applications concerned rulings of Humphreys J. on 13 June 2016, in judicial review proceedings against Judge Lucey and a judge of the District Court. Mr Lavery argued he was denied a hearing because counsel for the Director of Public Prosecutions appeared. The relief he sought was to quash a Cavan District Court order of 25 February 2016 remanding him to 15 April 2016. On 4 July 2016 Humphreys J. had also barred him from starting High Court proceedings without leave.

The Supreme Court said none of the applications raised a point of general public importance, and nothing justified a direct appeal. Any appeal would lie to the Court of Appeal. It added that Mr Lavery had failed to file the full papers or reply to correspondence from its office.

It awarded costs to the respondents, with a two-week stay during which Mr Lavery may make written submissions on costs.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal