localnews.ie

Gerard and Ann Kelleher refused Supreme Court appeal after fees appeal dismissed in their absence

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court said the Kellehers should first ask the Court of Appeal to reinstate their appeal against a judgment for legal fees.

The Supreme Court refused Gerard Kelleher and Ann Kelleher leave to appeal in a second determination delivered on 11 November 2016. The plaintiffs are Patrick Mullins, Juliette Lynch and Joan Byrne, practising as Mullins Lynch Byrne Solicitors.

The case began when Keane J. heard the solicitors' claim for legal fees in the High Court without the Kellehers or any representative present, and gave judgment for the plaintiffs. The Kellehers' appeal was transferred to the Court of Appeal. When it came back after an adjournment, they did not appear. They had sent a medical report seeking a further adjournment, and the Court of Appeal had said a doctor should attend or give oral evidence. None did, and the court dismissed the appeal on 27 July 2016 (Ryan P., Kelly P. and Edwards J.).

The Kellehers said they had been denied a chance to be heard, and pointed to professional negligence proceedings over the services behind the fees claim. The plaintiffs said the couple chose not to attend hearings they knew about.

The Supreme Court said a case going ahead in a party's absence does not by itself justify an appeal to it. It said the proper first step is an application to the Court of Appeal to reinstate the appeal, explaining the non-attendance. If that were refused, leave to appeal that decision could be sought. Leave was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal