localnews.ie

Gerard and Ann Kelleher refused Supreme Court appeal over solicitors coming off record

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The couple were sued for legal fees by Mullins Lynch Byrne Solicitors and challenged a ruling that let their own solicitors stop acting for them.

The Supreme Court refused Gerard Kelleher and Ann Kelleher leave to appeal in a determination delivered on 11 November 2016. The plaintiffs in the underlying case are Patrick Mullins, Juliette Lynch and Joan Byrne, practising as Mullins Lynch Byrne Solicitors, who sued the Kellehers for legal fees said to be owing.

The Kellehers had instructed James Coady & Sons Solicitors. That firm applied to come off record, and Birmingham J. granted the application in the High Court in Cork on 2 May 2014. The Kellehers were not present. The fees case was listed the same day and went ahead before Keane J. without them, and judgment was entered against them.

The Court of Appeal (Ryan P., Kelly P. and Edwards J.) dismissed their appeal against the order on 15 June 2016. It found that the Kellehers had been told the motion was moved forward and to Cork, and that there was evidence the relationship of trust with the firm had broken down.

The Kellehers argued that issues of justice arise when a motion is heard at a different time and place from the one in the notice of motion. The Supreme Court said the rules on when a solicitor may come off record are well established, and it saw an orthodox application of them here. It found no point of general public importance and refused leave.

The ruling does not concern the separate appeal against the fees judgment.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal