localnews.ie

Thomas Darcy refused Supreme Court appeal in Allied Irish Banks debt and property case

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

Darcy argued AIB breached an earlier Supreme Court order by dropping one set of proceedings and starting another after the law changed.

The Supreme Court refused Thomas Darcy leave to appeal in a determination delivered on 10 November 2016. Allied Irish Banks PLC is the plaintiff in the underlying case, and Mr Darcy's wife Antoinette Darcy is the second defendant.

AIB sought orders that very substantial debts allegedly owed by the Darcys stand well charged on certain properties. It succeeded in the High Court before Keane J., and the Court of Appeal (Charleton, Peart and Irvine JJ.) dismissed the Darcys' appeal on 14 July 2016.

The case has a history. AIB issued earlier proceedings for possession of the same properties on 22 July 2010, and McGovern J. granted an order for possession on 16 April 2012. On appeal the Supreme Court sent that case to a plenary hearing. AIB then discontinued it and began new proceedings, relying on the Land and Conveyancing Law Reform Act 2013.

Mr Darcy said AIB had not complied with the earlier Supreme Court order and that the Court of Appeal had no jurisdiction to interpret or vary it. The Supreme Court said he had misunderstood the order. It required the case to proceed as if begun by plenary summons, not to be taken to a final decision, and any such case can be discontinued. A party may use a change in the law by starting fresh proceedings. There was no substance to the point, and leave was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal