The Supreme Court refused Brian O'Donnell and Mary Patricia O'Donnell leave to appeal directly from the High Court, in a determination delivered on 9 November 2016. The respondent was Christopher Lehane, the Official Assignee.
The O'Donnells, who are bankrupts, wanted to challenge a decision of Costello J. delivered on 18 April 2016. She had refused an application to compel the Official Assignee either to let them lodge a motion to extend time to appeal a 2011 High Court judgment, or to assign them the right to bring that application. She also ordered that the Official Assignee recover the costs of the motion from them in person.
Costello J. relied on an earlier Supreme Court decision of 8 December 2015, which refused the couple's own application to extend time. That court (Denham C.J., MacMenamin and Laffoy JJ.) found that they lacked standing, because the right had passed to the Official Assignee when they were adjudicated bankrupt on 2 September 2013.
The O'Donnells said the order had been misunderstood and that the Court of Appeal route would only add cost. The Supreme Court said the interpretation of its order can be dealt with by any court, and urgency alone does not raise a point of general public importance. It said no issue warranted a direct appeal, and they can still appeal to the Court of Appeal.
The lawfulness of the costs order will be decided in a related matter, where leave was granted.