localnews.ie

Brian and Mary Patricia O'Donnell granted Supreme Court appeal over costs against bankrupts

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear the O'Donnells on whether courts can award costs against bankrupts personally, outside their bankruptcy estates, but not on their other grounds.

The Supreme Court has granted Brian O'Donnell and Mary Patricia O'Donnell leave to appeal on one point: whether costs can be awarded against bankrupts personally, outside their bankruptcy estates. The determination was delivered on 7 November 2016. The respondents are Christopher Lehane and the Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland.

The O'Donnells applied to the High Court under section 85C of the Bankruptcy Act 1988 to annul their adjudication as bankrupts. The petitions were based on a judgment the Bank of Ireland obtained in summary proceedings begun in December 2010. After a settlement agreement of 4 March 2011, and a default, the High Court (Kelly J.) entered judgment against them on 12 December 2011 for about €71.5 million. That judgment was not appealed. They were adjudicated bankrupt by Charleton J. on 2 September 2013, after a High Court in England and Wales refused their bid to be adjudicated bankrupt there.

Costello J. dismissed the annulment application and ancillary matters in the High Court, and the Court of Appeal (Finlay Geoghegan J., with Ryan P. and Peart J. concurring) dismissed their appeal.

The O'Donnells put forward four points they said were of general public importance. The Supreme Court rejected three of them. It said no issue of general importance arose in how the annulment application was dealt with, as the petitions rested on a final High Court judgment. It said the Bankers' Books Evidence Act point did not properly arise, and that how the High Court arranged to hear several motions together was a matter for that court.

On costs, the court said the question raises a point of some general importance. Leave is granted on the sole ground that the High Court and Court of Appeal erred in holding that they could award costs against the appellants outside their bankruptcy estates.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal