The Supreme Court refused Gary Campion leave to appeal in a determination delivered on 21 October 2016. The Director of Public Prosecutions was the respondent.
A Central Criminal Court jury convicted Campion by majority in May 2009 of the murder of Frank Ryan in September 2006 in Moyross, County Limerick, and he received the mandatory life sentence. A central part of the prosecution case was video-recorded statements from a key eyewitness identifying him as the killer. At trial the witness retracted them, and the trial judge admitted them under section 16 of the Criminal Justice Act 2006.
Campion challenged the admission of those statements, the trial judge's charge to the jury, and the fairness of his trial after a newspaper report. He also argued that remarks he allegedly made after arrest should have been excluded. The Court of Appeal rejected his arguments in a judgment of November 2015.
The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal had applied settled law and that the other points were matters for the facts of the case. It said that even if it accepted his wider definition of voluntariness, it would not help his appeal, because the claim of coercion had been rejected at trial and by the Court of Appeal. It extended the time for his application, but refused leave.