The Supreme Court has granted leave to appeal to both sides in a shareholder dispute over the company ELST, in a determination delivered on 18 October 2016. Leave went to Danbywiske, Ronald Wilson and the general partners of the Wilson Limited Partnership 1, and also to the petitioner, Donegal Investment Group PLC.
The case began as a petition under section 205 of the Companies Act 1963, with relief also sought under section 213(f). Donegal Investment, a shareholder in ELST, became unhappy with how the company was managed. Before the petition it was offered €25 million for a 30% stake, and its solicitors sought €34 million for a claimed 35%. In January 2015 McGovern J. decided in separate proceedings that it held 30%.
In the High Court, McGovern J. fixed the price at which Danbywiske should buy Donegal Investment's shares, using a multiplier of 6:1 based on transaction comparables only. He ordered the purchase on 5 June 2015. On 8 June 2016 the Court of Appeal (Finlay Geoghegan, Hogan and Cregan JJ.) vacated those orders. It held that the price should be the full current market value, and that the multiplier should be set after considering both transaction and trading comparables. It found the High Court's multiplier was a finding based on no evidence. A higher price for the shares is one possible result of returning to the High Court.
Danbywiske argued that the ruling is a radical departure from the principles in Hay v O'Grady on appeals against findings of fact, and has implications for how trial judges deal with expert evidence. Donegal Investment said the Court of Appeal correctly analysed the experts' evidence.
Donegal Investment also sought to appeal the Court of Appeal's costs order of August 2016, which vacated the High Court costs order and made no order on the costs of the appeal.
The Supreme Court said an issue of general public importance arises over expert evidence and how a trial judge chooses between differing opinions. It also accepted that whether an error of principle must be identified before a High Court costs order is overturned is of public importance. The appeal will cover whether the Hay v O'Grady principles limit appellate review of fact, including expert testimony, whether they were departed from in the share valuation rulings, and whether the costs order needs to be reviewed.