localnews.ie

John Wilkinson refused Supreme Court appeal over habeas corpus bid and consecutive sentences

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

Wilkinson argued his detention was unlawful because a three-month driving sentence depended on an assault sentence that was under appeal.

The Supreme Court declined to allow John Wilkinson to appeal a Court of Appeal decision on his detention, in a determination delivered on 10 October 2016. The respondent was the Governor of the Midlands Prison.

Mr Wilkinson was convicted of assault causing harm at Carlow District Court on 20 January 2016 and sentenced to nine months. While serving it, he was given a further three months by Athlone District Court for driving without insurance, to start when the first sentence legally expired. He then appealed the Carlow sentence, entered a bond of €1,000 and made a cash lodgement of €250.

He applied to the High Court for habeas corpus, arguing that the Athlone sentence could not take effect while the first was under appeal, so there was no live warrant for his detention. White J. refused this on 3 May 2016. The Court of Appeal (Birmingham, Sheehan and Mahon JJ.) dismissed his appeal on 24 June 2016, holding that appealing the first sentence brought forward the start of the second.

The Supreme Court said the case concerned the specific facts of one individual and was not of systemic importance. It also noted that a third valid warrant authorising his detention existed in the Court of Appeal, and that habeas corpus does not lie in those circumstances. It concluded he was not entitled to a further appeal.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal