The Supreme Court has granted Jonathan O'Sullivan leave to appeal against his conviction for burglary. The determination was delivered on 4 October 2016. The Director of Public Prosecutions is the respondent.
O'Sullivan was convicted by a jury after a two-day trial of burglary under the Criminal Justice (Theft and Fraud Offences) Act 2001 and sentenced to three years in prison. The case concerned an intruder in a woman's kitchen at about 7.40am on 22 July 2013. €100 was missing from her purse. About three months later she identified O'Sullivan at a formal identity parade.
At trial O'Sullivan gave evidence in line with a notice of alibi, saying he was with his girlfriend, and she supported his account. The prosecution then called rebuttal evidence that a garda had seen him at his home with his mother the previous evening, including a curfew book showing he had earlier been subject to a curfew order while on bail. The defence objected that it had not been told of this evidence in advance and that admitting it would make the trial unfair. The trial judge allowed it.
The Court of Appeal (Birmingham J., Sheehan J. and Mahon J.) dismissed his appeal on 10 May 2016. It was not satisfied that section 20(4) of the Criminal Justice Act 1984 puts any duty on a trial judge to direct disclosure, and held that fairness did not require advance warning that a witness's credibility might be attacked. It also said that, because O'Sullivan had put his own character in issue, advance disclosure did not arise.
O'Sullivan argued that the ruling affects future trials, where rebuttal of an alibi could suggest that an accused has a record or is known to gardaí. The DPP said the issues were specific to the facts and that no prosecution duty to disclose such material exists.
The Supreme Court was satisfied that the application raised issues of general public importance. It granted leave on two questions: what is the extent of the duty, if any, on the prosecution to disclose material in rebuttal of an alibi notice, and if there is such a duty, when disclosure must be made.